Methodology

How we calculate a fair roof price

Every number the estimator uses, where it comes from, and which ones are our own judgement calls.

All sources below were opened and checked on 2026-11-21. The estimator's numbers live in `data/price-data.json`. Anything marked Judgement call is Oki's reasoned choice based on the cited sources, not a figure published by anyone.

How the fair range is calculated

  • Roof squares. If the quote lists squares, we use that number. Otherwise: (home square feet ÷ stories) × slope factor × 1.05 for overhangs. The slope factor is √(1 + (rise/12)²), using rise 4, 6, 9 or 12 for the four pitch choices. HomeGuide's table (2,000 sq ft home → 2,235 sq ft of roof at 6:12) matches the slope factor; the 1.05 overhang allowance is a judgement call consistent with Angi (1,490 sq ft home → 1,800 sq ft of roof) and HomeAdvisor (roof ≈ 1.1–1.2 × house size).
  • Price per square = (installed price for the material + tear-off for the old layers) × metro factor × pitch multiplier × stories multiplier. Low and high ends are calculated separately.
  • Extras (decking, skylights, gutters, permit) are added at national prices with no metro adjustment.
  • Totals are rounded to the nearest $100. "Typical middle" is the midpoint of the range.
  • Verdict bands (judgement call): below 80% of the low end = "well below"; below the low end = "below"; inside the range = "fair" (split into lower, middle and upper thirds); up to 120% of the high end = "above"; more than 120% = "well above".

Price data

IDNumber usedValueSourceURLDate checked
S23-tab asphalt shingles, installed$3–$5 / sq ft = $300–$500 per squareHomeGuide, "How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? (2026)", Kristen Cramer, Nov 7, 2025homeguide.com/costs/roof-replacement-cost2026-11-21
S2Architectural shingles, installed$4–$6 / sq ft = $400–$600 per squareHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Standing-seam metal, installed$9–$16 / sq ft = $900–$1,600 per squareHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Corrugated / sheet metal panels, installed$5–$12 / sq ft = $500–$1,200 per squareHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Concrete tile, installed$7–$19 / sq ft = $700–$1,900 per squareHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Clay tile, installed$8–$25 / sq ft = $800–$2,500 per squareHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Old roof removal (first layer)$100–$300 per square (shingles/metal tear-off $1–$3 / sq ft)HomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Lifespans3-tab 15–20 yrs; architectural 20–30; metal 30–80+; tile 30–100+HomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Decking$2–$5 / sq ft installed (we use $64–$160 per 4x8 sheet = 32 sq ft × $2–$5)HomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2SkylightsReplace $800–$2,400; new install $1,600–$4,200HomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2GuttersReplace $12–$25 / linear ft; new $5–$15 / linear ftHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Permit$100–$500HomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2Line-item checksDrip edge $1.50–$3 / ft; underlayment material $0.10–$0.80 / sq ft; roof vent $200–$700; flashing replacement $400–$1,000; fascia $5–$12 / ft; soffit $4–$22 / ft; inspection $100–$400; truss $5–$14 / sq ftHomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S2National average (asphalt)$10,800; typical $5,700–$16,000HomeGuide (same page)link2026-11-21
S1Atlanta asphalt roofing replacementJob cost $29,851; resale $20,475; 68.6% recouped (national $31,871; South Atlantic $32,253)Remodeling / JLC, 2025 Cost vs Value Report, Atlanta, GAjlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/south-atlantic/atlanta-ga/2026-11-21
S1Atlanta metal roofing replacementJob cost $43,826; resale $26,959; 61.5% recouped (national $51,865)Same report and pagelink2026-11-21
S1What the CvV roofing job includes30 squares, tear-off to bare sheathing, min. 235-lb shingles, new underlayment, drip edge, flashing, rectangular hip roof, two skylights, vented ridgeJLC, "Roofing Replacement / Asphalt Shingles" project description, June 20, 2025jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/roofing-replacement-asphalt-shingles/2026-11-21
S1Atlanta metro factorAsphalt 0.937 (= 29,851 / 31,871); metal 0.845 (= 43,826 / 51,865). Tile: asphalt ratio used (Judgement call, no Atlanta tile figure published)Calculated from S1—2026-11-21
S3Cross-check: national roof costAverage $9,611; normal $5,903–$13,380; $4–$11 / sq ft; architectural $4–$6 / sq ft; tile $10–$20 / sq ft; removal $1,000–$3,000 + hauling $500–$1,500HomeAdvisor, "How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost?", updated Jun 17, 2026homeadvisor.com/cost/roofing/install-a-roof/2026-11-21
S4Atlanta averagesAverage $7,777; most pay $5,211–$10,355; $4–$11 / sq ft; 1,490 sq ft home ≈ 1,800 sq ft roof; average Atlanta permit ≈ $175Angi, "How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost in Atlanta? [2026 Data]", Dan Simms, updated Jul 8, 2026angi.com/articles/how-much-does-roof-replacement-cost/ga/atlanta2026-11-21
S5Cross-check and extra layersAverage ≈ $10,000; $7,500–$14,000; tear-off ≈ $50 per square, up to $150 for heavy or multiple layers; labor 40–60% of cost; solar remove/reinstall $500–$2,000Fixr, "How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? [2026 Data]", updated Feb 4, 2026fixr.com/costs/roof-replacement2026-11-21
S12Steep-roof labor (used for the pitch judgement)Past 8/12, labor +15–30%; very steep can nearly double labor timeAmerican Commercial Roofing (an Atlanta contractor, so treat as an industry opinion), updated Oct 4, 2026americancommercialroof.com/...atlanta-metro/2026-11-21

Judgement calls (not published figures)

  • Extra old layers: $50–$150 per square per extra layer, based on Fixr's ≈$50 average tear-off and "up to $150 for multiple layers".
  • Pitch multipliers: steep (8–9/12) ×1.07–1.15; very steep (10/12+) ×1.15–1.35. Reasoning: S12's 15–30% labor increase × Fixr's 40–60% labor share ≈ 6–18% of total; very steep is set higher because S12 says labor can nearly double.
  • Stories multipliers: 2-story ×1.00–1.05; 3+ stories ×1.05–1.10. HomeGuide lists multiple stories as a cost factor but gives no number.
  • Overhang allowance: ×1.05 (see method above).
  • Tile metro factor: uses the asphalt ratio 0.937.
  • Verdict bands: 80% / 120% thresholds.
  • Deposit red flag: we flag deposits over 30%. No Georgia deposit limit was found; HomeGuide advises not paying in full upfront.

Rules, laws and safety (used in red flags)

IDFactSourceURLDate checked
S6Talk to your insurer before repairs or inspection; be skeptical of deductible offers; roofers may not file claims unless they are or employ a licensed public adjuster; SB 201 (effective July 1, 2025): within 1 year of a natural disaster, contractors may not take assignment of insurance proceeds and must honor cancellation before midnight of the 5th business day after a written claim denial, with a Notice of Cancellation formGeorgia Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division, "Storms and Fraud"consumer.georgia.gov/consumer-topics/storms-fraud2026-11-21
S7Georgia does not require a roofing license; a legitimate roofer should provide references, business license, workers' comp, general liability, tax ID, written warranties, permanent address and phoneGeorgia AG Consumer Ed, Feb 4, 2025consumered.georgia.gov/ask-ed/2025-02-04/...2026-11-21
S8Roofers are specialty occupations not licensed by the state; general liability required for licensed contractors; workers' comp with 3+ employeesGeorgia AG Consumer Ed, Dec 13, 2023consumered.georgia.gov/ask-ed/2023-12-13/...2026-11-21
S10Misdemeanor to advertise or promise to pay or rebate any part of an insurance deductible, including a yard-sign discountO.C.G.A. § 33-23-43(c)(4), (d), (e), via Justia (2025 Georgia Code)law.justia.com/.../section-33-23-43/2026-11-21
S2Don't pay in full upfront; get 3+ estimates; get written estimate, contract and warrantyHomeGuide (roof replacement page)link2026-11-21

City housing data

IDDataSourceURLDate checked
S11Median year built (B25035), year built distribution (B25034), median home value (B25077), tenure (B25003), units in structure (B25024) for the 10 citiesU.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020-2024 5-year estimates, retrieved through the Census Reporter API (raw file: `data/acs2024_5yr_raw.json`)api.censusreporter.org2026-11-21

Sources looked at but not used for numbers

  • RSMeans city cost indexes: not publicly available for free, so not used.
  • Roofer and SEO blog pages (e.g. theroofingbrief.com, domroofing.com, mustangroof.com) quote Atlanta prices but are marketing or unverified aggregators. They were read only as a sanity check. Their Atlanta ranges ($8,000–$20,000 for typical homes) are close to our results.